| Alias | Category | Stage 1 | Stage 2 | Stage 3 | Stage 4 | Stage 5 | Stage 6 | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A.T. McGee | Cattle Baron | 33.00 | 21.78 | 48.18 | 33.85 | 59.81 | 37.29 | 233.91 |
| William Bowie | Senior Duelist | 30.37 | 10.07 | 80.39 | 40.87 | 50.96 | 46.09 | 258.75 |
| Idaho Muleskinner | Cattle Baron | 31.75 | 8.19 | 81.00 | 29.79 | 39.60 | 79.60 | 269.93 |
| Del Monte | Silver Senior | 28.00 | 21.78 | 67.48 | 38.03 | 77.64 | 38.35 | 271.28 |
| Granny Gun Smoke | Lady Silver Senior | 56.75 | 13.19 | 61.84 | 40.30 | 79.41 | 43.94 | 295.43 |
| Covada | Silver Senior | 50.37 | 65.07 | 45.64 | 26.75 | 51.61 | 63.27 | 302.71 |